Friday, January 9, 2015

The tragedy of the commons


It never gets prettier, it only gets uglier…

There were plenty of codfish in the Gulf of Maine when George Washington was president.

Your children might not be able to eat cod when they grow up.

It’s possible that, roughly speaking, there won’t be any codfish to eat.

NYTimes.com ran a piece a few days ago that asked “Where have all the cod gone?”

Here’s a quote from the reporting of W. Jeffrey Bolster:
“Overfishing has been the norm for a very long time, but the market has masked the mess in two fundamental ways. At every step fishermen confronting declining catches developed gear that fished more intensively, taking a larger percentage of the fewer fish that remained. Such a strategy was clearly not sustainable. Meanwhile, fishermen continued to earn enough to make fishing worthwhile, even if many encouraged their sons to pursue other careers because there would be little future in fishing. The Gulf of Maine cod stocks today are probably only a fraction of 1 percent of what they were during George Washington’s presidency.”



If there were only one fisherman, most likely she wouldn’t be dumb enough to overfish to the extent that there weren’t enough breeding cod left to replenish the stock.

Sadly, humans in groups generally are dumb enough to do just that.

The tragedy of the commons is a dangerous element of real life.










Copyright © Richard Carl Subber 2015

No comments:

Post a Comment